With the conclusion of the book, I am horrified. The psychological
manipulation that was a constant theme throughout the book is illuminated to
its fullest within the final portion of the novel. Here, we see the appalling
torture methods used by the Ministry of Love, an ironic name in itself. I think
the reason why this is so alarming is because Winston is the most rebellious
character introduced, even those among him in his cell were convicted of only
petty crimes. But he was willing to fight against the Brotherhood. By the end,
he submissively accepts the principles set forth by The Party and finds
comfort, rather than hatred, in the sight of the face of Big Brother. He
believes that "forty years it had taken him to learn what kind of smile
was hidden beneath the dark mustache” (245).
Even though it had been clear to the reader
through the duration of the novel that the meaning was the dangers of a
totalitarian rule, we can also see the possible outcomes if we as a populace
remain bystanders. Through the
characters of Julia and Winston, Orwell shows that although they’re rebellious
in manner, their actual actions remain submissive and are alike the other
bystanders. Their way of fighting Big Brother is doing activities that are prohibited,
such as sex and writing, rather than taking the initiative to destroy the
government. Even after he contacted the Brotherhood, his actions don't really change. Imagine if our Founding Fathers had never fought against the
British tyranny and remained docile. The empire would eventually become more
powerful and spread, just like Big Brother does.
1984 shows us the dangers of a totalitarian rule as well as the
consequences of remaining pliable. For it only allows the ruling class to prevail
and eventually enables people, like Winston, to “win the victory over himself” (245), referring
to his past mental hostility towards Big Brother and his transition into submissiveness.
With further investigation on Orwell, I was
surprised that to discover that he was actually a socialist. But his views
remained slightly ambiguous, due to expressing anarchist sentiments, a
contradictory view in itself. Usually, a socialist is for strong government. I think that he is against totalitarian rule like
Stalin, but believed in socialism as a feasible method of economics, being most
successful without the control of tyrannical rule. This brings up the question:
how much say should government have in economics or in people’s lives, if any at
all?
The article about his religious and political views can be seen here
All in all, I really enjoyed this book and the warning and consequences of totalitarian rule. But I think I should give dystopian novels a break for awhile, since that I have already read 3 of them this year. Though I have learned many important lessons from this book such as the importance of individualism, nonconformity, and balance of power in government.
Kyle, your post was very interesting. As a I read about the message of this novel, which regards the consequences or a totalitarian society, did you ever see similarities between this novel and Brave New World or Handmaid's Tale? If so, what?
ReplyDeleteYes, I thought 1984 and Brave New World were very similar. They both showed the consequences of a totalitarian society where the populace lacked original thoughts other than what the government told them to think. As for Handmaid's Tale, it was similar but different at the same time. There was more societal order in the 1984 society but there were also scenes within both books that held similar meaning.
DeleteHaving also picked 1984 as my novel, I was also horrified by the ending. It is interesting that a rebellious character like Winston still conformed to the Party in the end. Do you believe that it is unrealistic how the Party is able to control Winston's mind? Or, do you believe that this something that is possible in our world's future?
ReplyDeleteI appreciate the additional research you did on Orwell. It is often helpful to have some biographical information about the authors of books.
ReplyDelete